The Second Brain
The enteric nervous system — the network of neurons lining the gastrointestinal tract — contains an estimated 100–500 million neurons. It can function largely independently of the central nervous system, which led researchers to nickname it the "second brain."
The gut-brain axis refers to the bidirectional communication network connecting the gut and the brain through multiple pathways:
- The vagus nerve: the primary neural highway between gut and brain
- The enteric nervous system: the gut's own nervous system
- The immune system: gut immune activity can signal to the brain via cytokines
- The endocrine system: gut cells produce hormones including serotonin, ghrelin, and GLP-1
- The microbiome: gut bacteria produce neurotransmitters and neuroactive compounds that influence brain function
About 90% of the body's serotonin is produced in the gut — a striking statistic that underscores how gut function may influence mood.
What the Research Shows
Gut Microbiome and Mood
A landmark 2019 study in Nature Microbiology (Valles-Colomer et al.) analyzed data from over 1,000 individuals and found that depletion of Coprococcus and Dialister species was consistently associated with depression, even after controlling for antidepressant use. The researchers were careful to note this was associational, not causal.
A 2016 randomized controlled trial (Romijn et al., Nutritional Neuroscience) found that a multi-strain probiotic supplement produced small but statistically significant improvements on the Beck Depression Inventory compared to placebo in individuals with depression. Effect sizes were modest.
Psychobiotics
The term psychobiotic was coined by researchers Dinan, Stanton, and Cryan in a 2013 paper in Biological Psychiatry to describe live bacteria that produce mental health benefits. It has since expanded to include prebiotics with similar effects.
Key evidence from psychobiotic research:
- A 2015 randomized trial (Steenbergen et al., Brain, Behavior, and Immunity) found that a multi-strain probiotic (containing Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium species) reduced cognitive reactivity to sad mood in healthy volunteers, a marker of depression vulnerability.
- A 2019 meta-analysis (Pirbaglou et al.) found probiotics associated with small but consistent improvements in depression and anxiety scores across 34 controlled trials.
Effect sizes in psychobiotic research are generally small to moderate. These findings suggest gut-brain interventions are promising but are not yet positioned to replace established mental health treatments. The research field is young — most trials are short (4–8 weeks), use different probiotic strains and doses, and measure different outcomes.
Gut Microbiome and Cognition
A 2021 review in Nature Reviews Neuroscience (Cryan et al.) examined gut-brain axis effects on cognition and found growing evidence that the microbiome influences learning and memory through multiple pathways, including:
- Short-chain fatty acid production and neuroinflammation modulation
- Microbial tryptophan metabolism affecting serotonin and kynurenine pathways
- Direct vagal nerve signaling
Germ-free animal studies (animals raised without any gut bacteria) show significant cognitive impairments and anxiety-like behavior — though the relevance of extreme germ-free conditions to human gut health requires careful translation.
The Vagus Nerve: The Main Highway
The vagus nerve carries signals in both directions between the gut and brain, but roughly 80% of fibers run upward — from gut to brain — not downward. This means the gut may be sending far more signals to the brain than the brain sends to the gut.
Vagal tone — a measure of vagal activity — is associated with better heart rate variability, reduced inflammation, and better emotional regulation. Some research suggests that gut health and microbiome diversity may influence vagal signaling.
This is one reason why chronic gut inflammation may be associated with anxiety and depression in population studies — though the causal direction is almost certainly bidirectional and complex.
Supplements Being Researched for Gut-Brain Effects
1. Multi-strain Probiotics
As noted, several strains are being studied for psychobiotic effects. Lactobacillus helveticus R0052 and Bifidobacterium longum R0175 have the most consistent human evidence for mood effects. A 2011 RCT (Messaoudi et al., British Journal of Nutrition) found this combination reduced psychological distress and cortisol in healthy adults.
2. Prebiotic Fibers
A 2019 double-blind placebo-controlled study (Schmidt et al., Psychopharmacology) found that a prebiotic supplement (Bimuno — a GOS-based product) reduced cortisol awakening response and attentional vigilance to negative stimuli — consistent with anxiolytic effects.
3. L-Glutamine
Glutamine supports gut barrier integrity, and a compromised gut barrier has been associated with increased inflammatory signaling that may reach the brain. Some researchers hypothesize that reducing intestinal permeability via glutamine may have downstream mood effects, though direct human evidence for this mechanism is early.
4. Omega-3 Fatty Acids
While omega-3s are primarily studied for brain health directly (DHA is a structural component of neuronal membranes), there's growing evidence that omega-3s also reduce gut inflammation and may influence the microbiome — potentially contributing to mood effects through the gut-brain axis rather than purely through direct CNS effects.
5. Fermented Foods
A 2021 randomized controlled trial in Cell (Wastyk et al., n=36) found that a high-fermented food diet increased microbiome diversity and reduced inflammatory markers compared to a high-fiber diet. The gut-brain implications of this microbiome diversity increase are being actively studied.
What This Means Practically
The gut-brain axis research is compelling but still developing. The practical implications for most people likely include:
Pros
- +Growing evidence for specific probiotic strains reducing anxiety and depression markers
- +Dietary fiber and fermented foods may support mood via microbiome diversity
- +Low-risk interventions — improving gut health is beneficial regardless of mood effects
- +Addressing gut inflammation may reduce systemic inflammatory load affecting the brain
Cons
- -Effect sizes are small to moderate — not a replacement for established treatments
- -Most trials are short-duration with healthy volunteers
- -Strain specificity matters — not all probiotics have mood-relevant evidence
- -Individual microbiome variation means responses will differ significantly
The best strategy may be to treat gut health improvements as a long-term investment — the mood and cognitive benefits, if present, may develop gradually over weeks to months rather than acutely.
Related: Psychobiotics: Can Probiotics Actually Influence Your Mood? · Gut-Brain Axis: Microbiome, Energy, and Mood
Be the first to try Prova
We're building an app to track whether gut health and mood actually works. Join the waitlist.